Surfside Reverts Zoning Rules for Two Areas
A 3-2 vote undoes 2024 restrictions on home size and setbacks, ending a dispute over large single-family houses.
By Samuel Hayes ·

Surfside officials voted on Thursday to erase zoning changes adopted two years ago, restoring previous rules for single-family neighborhoods. The Town Commission passed a repeal measure by a 3-2 margin on second reading.
The vote reversed Ordinance 2024-1785, which had modified setback, yard, and lot standards in the H30A and H30B districts. Commissioners Andrea Travani and Gerardo Vildostegui opposed the repeal. Mayor Shlomo Danzinger, Vice Mayor Dayana Benmergui, and Commissioner David Weingot voted to bring back the older regulations.
The 2024 changes were enacted by a previous Commission that sought to limit the size of new homes. That group added floor area ratio limits and redefined lot coverage in the affected areas. The ordinance was a response to complaints about oversized construction. The current Commission decided to return to the standards that existed before those amendments were made.
Property owners challenged the 2024 rules under Florida’s Bert Harris Act, which allows compensation claims when regulations burden land value. In August 2025, the town settled a claim from the owner of 1429 Biscaya Drive. The settlement agreed not to enforce the new floor area limits on that specific lot.
Voters have weighed in on home size restrictions multiple times since the changes were introduced. In November 2024, residents approved charter amendments limiting lots west of Harding Avenue to single-family homes. However, two subsequent questions on floor area ratios failed. In April 2025, a proposed 0.50 cap for new homes lost 55% to 45%. Another question in March 2026, requiring four of five commissioners to change the rules, lost 54% to 46%.
Mayor Danzinger returned to office in April after defeating Vice Mayor Tina Paul in a runoff by 22 votes. The election resulted in four of five commission seats changing hands. The new leadership has moved quickly to alter the regulatory framework established by their predecessors.
During the final vote, commissioners made a technical correction to the ordinance text. They removed the phrase “or 10 feet minimum” from page 12. George Kousoulas, an architect and local resident, noted that the language was confusing without a clear minimum percentage. He stated that the sentence only made sense if 20% was the baseline.
Vildostegui expressed skepticism about the narrative surrounding the old and new codes. He said it seemed strange to associate the old code with freedom and the new one with restraint. Former Commissioner Eliana Salzhauer opposed the repeal, citing large concrete-like houses in the area. She supported the 10-foot minimum rule on Collins Avenue.
Danzinger argued that the previous code did not reflect the town's current desires. He cited 23 lawsuits and two failed referendums as evidence that the old rules were unpopular. He stated that the zoning residents were fighting to protect is not what the town wants.
The town has been applying the pre-2024 rules in the H30A and H30B districts while the repeal process was pending. The Town Attorney confirmed that a chart on page 8 of the ordinance required no changes. The repeal takes effect immediately following the vote.






