Jails absorb the weight of a failing mental health system
Experts and families describe a national gap in care where county prisons have become the primary destination for people in psychiatric crisis.
By Lauren Foster ·

The system meant to hold those who break the law has increasingly become the default option for those who need care. Experts state that prisons and county jails have shifted from places of confinement to de facto destinations for individuals requiring mental health treatment. This structural change places people in facilities not designed for long-term medical support.
Three specific facilities illustrate the scale of this issue. Rikers Island in New York, Twin Towers Jail in Los Angeles, and Cook County Jail in Chicago are among the largest mental health institutions in the country. The National Alliance on Mental Illness reports that 60% of people with a history of mental illness do not receive treatment while incarcerated. Once inside these walls, it becomes difficult for individuals to maintain medication regimens.
The consequences of this gap were felt in Ingham County, Michigan, in May 2024. Cynthia Marek called 911 for her son, Brandon Labrie, who was experiencing a mental health emergency. The crisis escalated into a stabbing within seconds. Labrie was subsequently charged with his mother's death. Steve Labrie, Brandon's father, worked as a registered nurse in state-run psychiatric hospitals for over three decades.
Steve Labrie said his son had attempted suicide by overdose weeks before the attack. The family was told Brandon would be placed in a long-term mental health facility, but that placement never occurred. "I've seen a lot of things in my life. It was, in my opinion, preventable," Steve Labrie said. He added that he does not know what type of treatment his son will receive, guessing it will be minimal if he receives any at all.
William Malcom runs mental health services for the Charleston County Sheriff's Office in South Carolina. He described his department as the largest mental health facility in the county, a role he believes they should not be holding. "I don't think this is really unique to Charleston County. This happens all over the country," Malcom said. He noted that jail often becomes the default when communities lack other options for people in crisis.
Some agencies are attempting to bridge the gap between police and mental health services. Zach Andrews serves as a mental health officer for Shelby County, Alabama. He responds to crisis scenes and trains deputies in crisis intervention. The approach involves sending a mix of officers and mental health clinicians to de-escalate situations and connect individuals to treatment. The first crisis intervention team model was developed in Memphis in the late 1980s and now exists in more than 2,700 communities across the U.S.
In North Carolina, a program called Forensic Assertive Community Treatment, or FACT, assists people with severe mental illness after release from jail or prison. The program provides mental health care, housing help, peer support, and court oversight. Angel Nelson, a peer support specialist for the FACT team in Mecklenburg County, said the program saved her life after years of addiction and repeated jail time. She started abusing drugs at age 9 and committed her first crime a few years later. A judge gave her a choice between extensive treatment or a lifetime behind bars.
Nelson said the first time she went to a store by herself and did not steal, she felt an emotion she had never experienced. "I get so emotional because I never knew I could do that," she said. In April 2026, Brandon Labrie agreed to plead guilty but mentally ill to second-degree murder. In May 2026, a judge sentenced him to 25 to 50 years in prison.






