Would an Eisenkot government really be less right wing than Netanyahu's?
Israel's opposition bloc promises a break from the divisive far right coalition of Benjamin Netanyahu, but many of its leading figures share similar positions on Palestinians, settlements and security.
By News Media House Staff ·

As complex negotiations to form Israel's next government drag on, hopes are high that former military chief Gadi Eisenkot will be able to build a coalition that breaks with the far right and divisive politics of the previous administration.
The coalition assembled by the now caretaker Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu brought figures from Israel's far right into government. Beyond the war on Gaza that followed the Hamas-led attack of October 7, 2023, and repeated military strikes against neighbouring countries, it sought to weaken judicial oversight and pursued an aggressive policy of settlement expansion in the occupied West Bank, where settler attacks on Palestinian communities have continued with near impunity.
"Likud sits further to the right than most conservative parties in Europe," said Roi Zur, an Israeli academic at the University of Essex who has compared Israeli parties with their international equivalents. Although historically seen as something like the Conservative Party, he said, "today it looks like something of a far-right party."
Eisenkot and his opposition bloc have said they will repeal the judicial overhaul legislation introduced under Netanyahu, establish a state commission of inquiry into the security failings ahead of the October 7 attack, and end the draft exemption offered to many ultra-Orthodox youth in defiance of a 2024 Supreme Court ruling.
Before any fresh alliances are brokered, five main leaders anchor the bloc. Eisenkot, head of the Yashar Party, is generally regarded as a centrist security hawk. Naftali Bennett and Yair Lapid of the B'Yachad Party are considered right wing and centre liberal respectively. Avigdor Lieberman of Yisrael Beiteinu is secular and right wing, while Yair Golan of the Democrats is the sole outlier on the left.
Eisenkot's own politics are widely seen as difficult to read. He has been broadly supportive of the war on Gaza, in which more than 74,600 Palestinians have been killed, and of attacks on countries across the region, including the current war on Iran. Little is known of his domestic positions, though his party's economic platform points to a broadly pro-market approach that prioritises tax cuts over wealth redistribution.
On security there is less ambiguity. Eisenkot is the architect of the Dahiya doctrine, a military strategy calling for overwhelming force against areas from which Israel comes under attack. In 2008 he warned that Israel's destruction of large parts of southern Beirut's Dahiya area in the 2006 Lebanon war "will happen in every village from which fire is launched toward Israel". This March, he said the doctrine should again be used in Lebanon and had "never been more relevant".
Eisenkot has also firmly rejected a Palestinian state and supports the continued existence of settlements in the West Bank, even as he pledges to tackle settler violence. His potential partners hold similar ground. Bennett, a former settler council chief, opposes Palestinian statehood and has said he favours annexing 60 percent of the West Bank. Lapid backs a two-state solution, but only in the long term and without firm details. Lieberman, once Netanyahu's ally and now one of his fiercest critics, has been vocal in supporting settlement expansion.
Both Bennett and Lieberman have made incendiary remarks about Palestinians: Bennett defended cutting off water and electricity to Gaza in October 2023, and Lieberman said in December 2023 that there were "no innocents in Gaza". Bennett and Lapid's 2021 coalition, which included the United Arab List, a party representing Palestinian citizens of Israel, collapsed the following year, partly over the privileges settlers receive in the West Bank. How the left wing Golan and the right wing Lieberman would work in one coalition remains to be seen; Or Tuttnauer of the University of Mannheim describes Golan's Democrats, a merger of the Labour and Meretz parties, as holding "liberal, progressive, dovish, secular positions", while Lieberman's party defines itself through secularism and fierce opposition to Netanyahu.
Whether such a coalition could be called liberal is doubtful. Israel occupies roughly 7,252 square kilometres (2,800 square miles) of Palestinian and Syrian territory and rules over some 5.5 million Palestinians who have no vote in the state that controls them, and polling suggests Israeli society shifted sharply to the right after the October 7 attack. "Many people have pinned their hopes on Netanyahu leaving, imagining that a moderate or even progressive government would follow," said HA Hellyer of the Royal United Services Institute. "But the problem was never just Netanyahu." He added that it would take years before Israelis accept the case for withdrawing from Gaza, the West Bank, "or even Syria and southern Lebanon".
Originally published by News Media House






