Empty Smokehouses Mark Tension in Alaska Senate Race
Pollock trawlers caught 40,000 salmon this year, a bycatch issue now central to the debate between Dan Sullivan and Mary Peltola.
By Samuel Hayes ·

The drying racks in Kwethluk, Alaska, are mostly bare this fall. For Evon Waska, who lives at the edge of the Kuskokwim River, the lack of fish is a daily reminder of a changing environment. He points to his smokehouse, a structure that should be full of salmon but sits empty instead. Waska says he and his neighbors are being forced to stop fishing while large industrial boats continue to operate offshore.
The conflict centers on pollock trawlers, which use nets a quarter mile long to catch whitefish. These boats are part of a $1 billion industry, much of which is based in Seattle. While the target catch is pollock, the nets also scoop up king salmon and other species. This accidental catch, known as bycatch, is a growing source of anger in western Alaska. According to industry figures, pollock trawlers have caught 40,000 Alaska salmon so far this year.
In the state’s tight U.S. Senate race, this issue has become the primary dividing line. Incumbent Republican Dan Sullivan, who has long supported the pollock industry, is now promoting a new bill to reduce bycatch. He described the legislation as the most comprehensive effort ever to protect seafloor habitat and reduce accidental catches. Sullivan’s campaign argues that his bill will help sustain local fisheries.
Democratic challenger Mary Peltola, who is Indigenous and from the Kuskokwim region, is taking a harder line. She proposes a ban on factory trawlers, the largest vessels in the fleet. Peltola calls Sullivan’s new bill an election year ploy. She notes that Sullivan has received more than $300,000 from trawlers and waited until late in the process to offer a solution she considers insufficient.
Heather Mann, who leads a trawlers association, disagrees with the idea that the pollock fishery is the main culprit. She states that even if pollock fishing were eliminated entirely, the impact on salmon runs would be minimal according to current science. She argues that blaming the industry is a way to deflect from other factors affecting the river.
For many residents in remote villages, the debate feels personal. Mary Nikolai, the tribal president of Kwethluk, walked into a neighbor's cold smokehouse this summer and found it unused. She said that most local smokehouses are in the same condition. Nikolai described the situation as a slow trend of closing out local workers who depend on subsistence fishing for their livelihood and cultural identity.
The race could decide the balance of power in the U.S. Senate. While the outcome in Washington is far away, the residents of western Alaska feel the immediate effects of the declining fish population. The empty smokehouses serve as a physical symbol of the stakes in this election.
Waska says he is up against an industry that operates miles offshore. He points to the contrast between the restrictions placed on local families and the continued operations of the large trawlers. He says, "They don't close the trawlers. They close me and my people first."






