New Haven insurers deny injury claims over fault and deadlines
Five common reasons for rejection include shared blame, unknown hazards, prior injuries, treatment gaps, and missed notice windows.
By Fatima Saleh ·

Insurance companies in New Haven are rejecting injury claims at a high rate, often citing five specific defenses that reduce payouts or eliminate them entirely. These denials typically arrive weeks after a crash or fall, leaving claimants to manage rising medical bills and lost wages without immediate compensation. The rejections rely on state statutes and legal precedents that insurers argue favor the company over the injured party.
The first common reason for denial is a claim of shared fault. Under General Statutes Section 52-572h, an insurer lowers the payment to match the claimant's percentage of responsibility. If the claimant is found more than 50 percent at fault, they receive nothing. Insurers rarely disclose how they calculate these percentages, but legal experts note that the decision can be challenged. Attorneys can gather photos, witness statements, and store video to determine who had the right of way or who caused the slip. This evidence can lower the assigned blame percentage and restore part of the claim.
A second frequent defense involves property owners who claim they did not know about a hazard, such as an icy step or wet floor. Connecticut law requires the claimant to prove the owner knew about the specific problem or should have found it during a basic check. Winter weather complicates this, as owners may argue they had reasonable time to clear ice after a storm. Lawyers counter this by requesting inspection records, cleaning schedules, and weather reports. They also seek video showing employees walking past the hazard without addressing it.
Insurers often deny claims by blaming a pre-existing injury for the current pain. Adjusters review medical histories and may contact previous doctors to argue that an old condition, such as a back problem, caused the pain rather than the new incident. To counter this, attorneys ask current doctors to provide notes comparing the patient's condition before and after the event. These notes clarify what symptoms existed previously and what the new incident added.
A gap between the incident and the first doctor visit is another reason for denial. Insurers argue that a delay indicates the injury was not serious, despite medical evidence that symptoms like whiplash can take days to appear. Lawyers collect urgent care notes, pharmacy receipts, and messages to employers to document when symptoms started and why treatment was delayed. Doctors can then add notes explaining how the symptoms progressed over time.
Finally, municipalities often reject claims related to roads or sidewalks if the claimant missed a notice deadline. Under Section 13a-149, written notice must be given within 90 days of the injury. In a 2025 Appellate Court decision, the court ruled in favor of New Haven because a woman injured in the Pitkin Street Tunnel could not prove the clerk's office received her notice. Attorneys handle this by sending notices via certified mail and keeping proof of delivery. They also track the two-year statute of limitations for filing suit, which starts when the injury is known or should have been known, with an outside limit of three years from the act.
Claimants who receive a denial letter should read it carefully to identify the exact reason for rejection. They should then request written proof from the company. Keeping appointments and saving records is essential, especially if a city road or sidewalk was involved. If the stated reason does not match the facts, a Connecticut lawyer can review the file before the claimant responds.






