Karina’s Law: Chicago police serve 3 of 91 gun warrants
The department cites safety concerns for delaying executions, while advocates argue the current approach leaves survivors exposed to risk.
By Fatima Saleh ·

Chicago police have served only three of the 91 search warrants issued under Karina’s Law since the statute took effect in May 2025, according to documents reviewed by the Chicago Sun-Times. The law allows courts to order the seizure of firearms from domestic abusers who hold protective orders.
The low execution rate has drawn criticism from legal aid groups and survivors who say the department is relying on voluntary compliance rather than mandatory enforcement. A police spokesperson stated that the department prioritizes the safety of all individuals involved during weapon recovery. They noted that many guns are still secured through voluntary surrender or during standard arrests.
Dominique, a 26-year-old mother, described an incident this summer where her ex-boyfriend pointed a gun at her head. She obtained a protective order and a search warrant in September. Officers had 96 hours to execute the warrant but returned to court two days later to ask Judge Lester Finkle to drop it. The officer argued that too much time had passed to confirm the firearm remained in the suspect’s home.
Legal Aid Chicago managing attorney Benna Crawford called the department’s reliance on voluntary surrender a flawed system that the law was designed to fix. She noted that suburban law enforcement agencies have served every warrant directed to them, recovering guns in each instance. In contrast, Crawford said police failed to execute warrants in cases involving more than 30 of the firm’s clients. In nearly every case, officials requested judges to negate the warrants based on concerns about outdated information.
Of the three warrants Chicago police did serve, one in July 2025 resulted in the recovery of two guns, and another in October 2025 yielded four. A third search in July, conducted during a criminal case, found 26 firearms in a Bridgeport home. Counterterrorism Chief Christopher Papaioannou acknowledged the difficulty of corroborating information within the expedited timeframe but credited officers for their efforts.
State Sen. Celina Villanueva, a chief sponsor of the law, described the current enforcement gap as a problem requiring legislative attention. Meanwhile, nonfatal domestic shootings in Chicago have risen by 25 percent this year compared to 2025, with 69 people shot and wounded by a partner so far this year. Dominique’s protective order remains unserved as she continues to live with her child, waiting for the system to act on the court’s directive.






