22% of Eighth Graders Meet Civic Literacy Standards in New NAEP Data
A student-authored piece for the Greensboro Herald outlines gaps in financial and media education within Minnesota's high school mandates.
By Samuel Hayes ·

Minnesotan students graduate from high school with a focus on college admissions, standardized testing, and grade point averages, but they often lack practical skills for managing personal finances and participating in civic life. A commentary published by MinnPost and partner outlets details how this educational gap leaves young adults unprepared for the economic and political realities of adulthood.
The National Assessment of Educational Progress reports that only 22% of U.S. eighth graders achieve proficiency in civic literacy. This statistic underscores the gap between mandated curriculum and actual student mastery. The author, a current high school student, notes that peers at a private school struggle with basic financial tasks despite their families' ability to manage investments and retirement funds. Specific gaps include opening savings accounts, building stock portfolios, and obtaining credit.
Minnesota law requires high schools to teach financial literacy, yet the National Financial Educators Council has issued a failing grade for the state's implementation. The mandate lacks a required statewide vetted curriculum and does not mandate specific educator training beyond general licenses. Students can complete the course without passing performance-based assessments, which the author argues leads to passive learning rather than skill acquisition.
Civic education faces similar structural challenges. While mandates exist for civics classes, education rates are declining. The author points to the recent Operation Metro Surge by Immigration and Customs Enforcement as a catalyst for learning. During this period, social media influencers informed students of their rights, including the right to privacy and the requirement for a judicial warrant for arrest. However, the author observes that students were only able to cite specific constitutional amendments after the immediate danger had emerged.
In response to these recent events, the author's school introduced mandatory civics blocks for sophomores. These rotating periods covered recent political decisions, the branches of government, gerrymandering, and the legal implications of hanging the Ten Commandments in classrooms. The author argues that learning about civil liberties should not wait for a civic emergency to occur.
Media literacy represents a third area of concern. A recent state of Minnesota study found that 45% of college faculty identified weaknesses in how first-year students evaluate source credibility. The author describes encountering AI-generated falsehoods on TikTok and notes that algorithmic feeds often prioritize specific news outlets, such as CNN or MSNBC, depending on user interaction. This creates a fragmented understanding of current events among students.
The author calls on the 2027 Minnesota Legislature to reform requirements and curricula for personal financial management, civic education, and media literacy. The piece suggests that budget investments should target these areas to ensure students gain functional knowledge. The commentary concludes by citing Abraham Lincoln's view that the philosophy of the schoolroom in one generation becomes the philosophy of government in the next, linking educational quality directly to future democratic participation.
This report is based on a commentary produced by ThreeSixty Journalism’s 2026 Opinion and Commentary Workshop for youth. The workshop operates in partnership with MinnPost, Minnesota Reformer, Minnesota Star Tribune, and Sahan Journal. The organization aims to equip young Minnesotans with skills in multimedia journalism and critical analysis.
More Business · Scam Watch · Report a business · Got a Story?






