Judge Keeps Murdaugh Murder Case Alive for 2027 Retrial
Alex Murdaugh's motion to dismiss indictments was rejected after a judge found the defense's claims of grand jury errors insufficient to halt the case.
By Fatima Saleh ·

Alex Murdaugh will face a new trial for the murders of his wife and son after a South Carolina judge rejected his latest legal bid to end the case. Judge Debra McCaslin denied the motion to dismiss on Friday, clearing the path for proceedings scheduled for next year.
The defense argued that the original indictments relied on false testimony from David Owen, a former State Law Enforcement Division agent who served as the chief investigator. Defense attorney Jim Griffin claimed Owen knowingly misled the Colleton County grand jury about key pieces of physical evidence.
Griffin stated that Owen told the grand jury blood spatter was found on Murdaugh's shirt the night of the killings, even though no such blood was detected. The attorney also asserted that Owen incorrectly told the grand jury that guns found on the property held the same ammunition load as the weapon used to kill Paul Murdaugh.
During the original 2023 trial, Owen testified that he believed the blood spatter claim was accurate at the time of his grand jury testimony. He said he did not see a report confirming the absence of human blood on the shirt until after Murdaugh had already been indicted. Owen also acknowledged that he had inaccurately described the similarity in ammunition loads between the various firearms and the murder weapon. He stated that he was not attempting to deceive the grand jurors.
Prosecutor Creighton Waters countered that the defense's arguments were weak because the claims about the shirt were believed to be true when Owen first presented them. Waters argued that other compelling evidence, including audio from a video on Paul's cell phone, would have supported the indictment regardless of the two disputed points. The audio reportedly captured all three family members together moments before the shooting.
The retrial is set for April 5, 2027, in Sumter County. This location was chosen after McCaslin granted a change of venue. The new trial follows the South Carolina Supreme Court's decision earlier this year to overturn the 2023 convictions. The high court cited shocking jury interference by the court clerk during the Colleton County proceedings.
Murdaugh remains in prison while awaiting this new trial. He is currently serving sentences for separate financial crimes. He pleaded guilty to those charges and was sentenced to 27 years in state prison and 40 years in federal prison. The attorney has admitted to stealing from clients but continues to deny killing Maggie Murdaugh, 52, and Paul Murdaugh, 22.
Both victims were found dead from multiple gunshot wounds at the family's hunting estate in 2021. Prosecutors indicated they were ready to seek new grand jury indictments as early as next month if the original ones had been dismissed. Judge McCaslin confirmed the prosecution could meet the December 10 session deadline to keep the April 2027 trial date intact.






