Congress moves to tax investment income after California rejects billionaire levy
With Democrats set to control Congress, tax experts argue the next push will focus on closing loopholes for the wealthy rather than implementing a new wealth tax.
By Samuel Hayes ·

California voters rejected a proposal to impose a one-time tax on billionaires earlier this month. The defeat marks the latest attempt by a state government to directly tax the net worth of its richest residents. With Democrats set to regain power in Congress next year, debate has shifted toward federal strategies for raising revenue from high-net-worth individuals.
Ray Madoff, a tax law professor at Boston College and author of "The Second Estate: How the Tax Code Made an American Aristocracy," told WFDD Public Radio that the current tax system has evolved away from its original design. The system was built to place the greatest burden on the wealthiest Americans. Instead, Madoff said, the richest now often avoid taxes altogether because the code heavily taxes wages while allowing investment and inheritance income to escape levies.
The federal government collected roughly $5 trillion in taxes in recent years. It spent approximately $7 trillion, creating a deficit of $2 trillion. Meanwhile, the wealthiest 1% of Americans hold $60 trillion in assets. Madoff noted that while high-income earners such as doctors and lawyers pay the vast majority of income taxes, those with great wealth avoid the burden by avoiding taxable income.
Madoff identified two main hurdles for wealth taxes. At the state level, residents can move to avoid the tax, a challenge illustrated by the opposition in California from both billionaires and Democratic leadership who feared the measure would undermine economic growth. At the federal level, the current Supreme Court is likely to find a wealth tax unconstitutional.
To address the revenue gap without creating a new constitutional battle, Madoff suggested Congress broaden the income tax base. This approach would subject investment gains and inheritances to the same income tax rules that apply to wages. He argued this method could raise necessary revenue and potentially lower tax rates for other Americans.
The estate tax, which has historically served as a catch-all for wealth, has lost its effectiveness. Over the past 36 years, the estate and gift tax has raised only $28 billion, a small figure relative to the wealth held by the top 1%. In 2025, when the richest 1% owned over $50 trillion, the estate tax provided little revenue. Madoff stated that the current system allows large gifts, such as a $100 million transfer, to go unreported by the recipient, unlike smaller windfalls that require reporting to the IRS.
Madoff emphasized that the pressure to tax wealth stems from the disconnect between national spending and the assets of the ultra-rich. He believes that integrating investment and inheritance income into the federal income tax system offers a practical path for the new Congress to increase revenue.
More Politics · Greensboro news · Report a business · Got a Story?






